Skip to main content

Table 3 Parenting stress (EBI parent domain), Parental and Child Mental Health Problems [STADI (parents), CSF (infants), SDQ (toddlers)]

From: Easing pandemic-related restrictions, easing psychosocial stress factors in families with infants and toddlers? Cross-sectional results of the three wave CoronabaBY study from Germany

 

Wave I (Feb. 21–June 21)

Wave II (June 21–Oct. 21)

Wave III (Oct. 21–March 22)

Wave I versus Wave II

Wave II versus Wave III

Wave I versus Wave III

% (n)

Statistical significancea (Effect size φ)

Parenting stress (EBI)

Comparison of dichotomized data: not stressed versus stressed/ strongly stressed

 Not stressed

61.8 (609)

53.9 (493)

48.8 (474)

* (0.08)

n.s. (0.052)

* (0.131)

 Stressed

30.2 (297)

33.4 (305)

39.8 (387)

 Strongly stressed

8.0 (79)

12.7 (116)

11.4 (111)

Parental mental health problems (STADI)

Comparison of dichotomized data: far below/ below average/ average versus above/ far above average

 Mothers

  Far below average

3.9 (36)

3.6 (31)

3.7 (33)

n.s. (0.02)

n.s. (0.025)

n.s. (0.045)

  Below average

11.4 (105)

12.5 (107)

11.4 (103)

  Average

60.4 (556)

57.9 (497)

56.7 (510)

  Above average

20.5 (189)

22.8 (196)

24.6 (221)

  Far above average

3.7 (34)

3.1 (27)

3.7 (33)

 Fathers

  Far below average

8.5 (5)

1.8 (1)

1.4 (1)

n.s. (−0.139)

n.s. (0.168)

n.s. (0.033)

  Below average

8.5 (5)

14.3 (8)

10.8 (8)

  Average

57.6 (34)

69.6 (39)

59.5 (44)

  Above average

18.6 (11)

8.9 (5)

23.0 (17)

  Far above average

6.8 (4)

5.4 (3)

5.4 (4)

Child mental health problems (CFS/ SDQ)

 Infant crying, feeding and sleeping problems (CSF)

   

  Excessive crying (rule of three)

1.8 (18)

2.5 (23)

2.4 (24)

n.s. (0.023)

n.s. (−0.002)

n.s. (0.021)

  Crying/ Whining/ Sleeping

26.5 (148)

31.5 (134)

35.5 (149)

n.s. (055)

n.s. (0.042)

* (0.097)

  Feeding

35.1 (196)

38.1 (162)

36.9 (155)

n.s. (0.031)

n.s. (−0.013)

n.s. (0.019)

 Toddlers’ emotional and behavioral problems (Categorial evaluation of SDQ total score)

Comparison of dichotomized data: no problems versus borderline/ noticeable problems

  No problems

81.6 (363)

77.6 (398)

76.1 (440)

   

  Borderline

10.1 (45)

11.5 (59)

11.6 (67)

n.s. (0.049)

n.s. (0.017)

n.s. (0.066)

  Noticeable problems

8.3 (37)

10.9 (56)

12.3 (71)

   
  1. *p ≤ 0.05
  2. aAdjusted for children’s age and sex. Effect size φ: < 0.01 indicates a small effect, 0.3 a medium effect and 0.5 a large effect
  3. EBI- German Version of Parenting Stress Index (‘Eltern-Belastungs-Inventar’), STADI: State-Trait-Anxiety-Depression Inventory, CFS: Questionnaire for Crying, Sleeping and Feeding, SDQ: Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire